Wednesday, June 15, 2011

What happened on May 21, 2011?

I'm reproducing here a nice little note that I thought was good.

Once again (of course) hope springs eternal and thousands of Christians have made fools of themselves and a laughingstock of the real Gospel message due to bad exegesis and die-hard traditions.  Why do they always want the world to end?

This note sums up the latest attempt quite nicely.

by David Vaughn Elliott

Nothing happened on May 21, 2011 -- except that followers of Harold Camping were frustrated while he was "flabbergasted" and "looking for answers."  With mounting pressure, he gave his "answers" publicly Monday evening, the 23rd.  He said his mistake was in viewing it all from a physical viewpoint.  He continued to claim his whole dating system is correct, but that  May 21 was fulfilled in a spiritual sense.  "We didn't see any difference, but God brought Judgement Day to bear on the whole world."

Sound familiar?  "Spiritual fulfilment" is the way Seventh-Day Adventists explain Miller's failed predictions in 1844.  It's the way so-called Jehovah's Witnesses explain Russell's false predictions of 1914.

Many of us believe in spiritual fulfilments of various OT prophecies.  So, are Camping's claims any different from ours?  Yes!  Contrary to Camping's "we didn't see any difference," the spiritual fulfilments we believe in were clearly evident.

Take for example the prediction in Malachi of the coming of Elijah.  Jesus said John the Baptiser fulfilled the prediction.  It was a spiritual fulfilment in the sense that Elijah himself did not come.  Nevertheless, John was seen and heard by "all Judea" (Matt. 3:5), making a great impact in preparation for the Messiah, Jesus.

Another example is the OT prediction of a coming kingdom.  Many of us believe Jesus' church is the fulfilment.  A spiritual fulfilment, yes, in the sense that the kingdom is a spiritual one.  Nonetheless, on Pentecost, A.D. 30, Jerusalem heard and saw a tremendous supernatural display (Acts 2).  That day, a great movement began which, within years, "turned the world upside down" (Acts 17:6).

In contrast, Adventists, Witnesses, and Campingites claim fulfilments that are imperceptible, undetectable.  As Camping put it, "we didn't see any difference."

Let truth be told: we didn't see any difference because there was no difference.  All three groups claim something happened when nothing happened.  They refuse to admit the obvious -- that their predictions failed.

The only "spiritual" fulfilment Camping has even mentioned, to my knowledge, is of "Judgement Day."  He claims everyone is now judged and salvation is no longer possible.

That's a daring statement, which calls for God's response: "When a prophet speaks in the name of the Lord, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the Lord has not spoken, but the prophet has spoken it presumptuously: you shalt not be afraid of him" (Deut. 18:22).

Camping dared to speak in the name of the Lord when the Lord said nothing of the kind.  Now, his claim that salvation is no longer available is nothing short of satanic.

Camping also predicted that on May 21 there would be world-wide earthquakes, throwing open graves, ushering in the Rapture.  The best I can gather, Camping now says that these failed predictions will take place together with the end of the world.  He continues to claim that the end will take place on Oct. 21, 2011.

So, unless I have missed it, Camping claims neither a physical nor a spiritual earthquake or rapture on May 21 -- he simply ignores this non-fulfilment.

Contrary to his claim, his dating system is false.

As various brethren have pointed out, predicting dates for Jesus' return and the end of the world is not only contrary to Scripture and futile; it also misguides the gullible and provides fodder for the mockers of Christianity.  Rather than set dates, God's message for us every day continues to be "Watch and pray: for you know not when the time is" (Mark 13:33).

(You can read more of Vaughn's insights at his website:

What continues to surprise me is how so many people can go on for so long ignoring the most fundamental principle of any reading for interpretation and meaning: find out who was being spoken to.


  1. "Spiritual fulfilment" is the Jehovah's Witnesses explain Russell's false predictions of 1914.

    The reason it worked for Jehovah’s Witnesses is that world events seemed to back up their interpretation. 1914 saw the outbreak of the greatest war in history (to that time) the first time ever the entire world went to war simultaneously. Immediately followed by the greatest pestilence ever…the Spanish Infuenza.

    Thus, their explanation of Rev 12:7-9 and early verses of Matt 24 seemed credible., that establishment of the Kingdom would temporarily result in horrendous conditions on earth.

    But what does Camping have? A spurt of lousy weather?

  2. You're right, Tom, but all the events of that period can't substantiate nor justify the simple fact of misplaced, alarmist predictions that did not come to pass.

    The Lord did NOT "return" in the Glory and revenge of he Father in 1914 and no amount of "spiritualising" can change what happened.

    What he said he would do, he did. And exactly when he said he'd do it, too! Before one generation had passed!